Logo
Browse Categories
All

Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you).

health-beauty
•Updated 12mo ago

Best cologne

Best cologne

TL;DR: Sauvage, Bleu de Chanel & Aventus are top compliment-getters but often called overused; performance is a key decider, with EDP/Parfum versions preferred for longevity; clones are a popular budget alternative for expensive scents

8.5K comments analyzed
r/malefashionadvice
1
Bleu de Chanel

Bleu de Chanel

$145.00Amazon
95

TL;DR: Classy compliment magnet; very versatile; EDP/Parfum longer lasting; some find it generic

5805
288
•277 positive•6 neg
2
Dior Sauvage

Dior Sauvage

$142.99Amazon
92

TL;DR: Popular compliment-getter; EDP/Elixir often preferred; many find it overused or generic

4167
322
•289 positive•26 neg
3
YSL Y

YSL Y

$121.12Amazon
91

TL;DR: Huge compliment getter; great performance; EDP version widely recommended; sweet apple & fresh

4335
178
•177 positive•1 neg
4
Versace Eros

Versace Eros

$64.99Amazon
88

TL;DR: Popular clubbing scent; sweet, minty & loud; gets many compliments; Flame version offers a spicier twist

3555
292
•282 positive•3 neg
5
Acqua di Gio

Acqua di Gio

$130.00Amazon
85

TL;DR: Classic fresh & clean scent; very versatile; Profumo/Parfum versions offer better performance

2790
295
•292 positive•1 neg
6
Creed Aventus

Creed Aventus

$510.00Amazon
81

TL;DR: Iconic compliment magnet; very expensive; many clones available; batch variations affect scent/performance

2078
249
•243 positive•6 neg
7
YSL La Nuit de L'Homme

YSL La Nuit de L'Homme

$75.99Amazon
77

TL;DR: Iconic seductive scent; huge compliment getter; cardamom & lavender notes; poor performance on newer batches

2984
181
•177 positive•4 neg
8
Paco Rabanne 1 Million

Paco Rabanne 1 Million

$67.99Amazon
74

TL;DR: Sweet & loud scent for nights out; gets compliments but divisive; Lucky & Elixir flankers are popular

2053
189
•180 positive•7 neg
9
D&G The One

D&G The One

$175.00Amazon
70

TL;DR: Widely loved warm, spicy & amber scent; great for date nights; notoriously poor performance & longevity

1801
157
•146 positive•9 neg
10
Versace Dylan Blue

Versace Dylan Blue

$66.45Amazon
66

TL;DR: Versatile fresh, clean & slightly sweet scent; excellent value & performance; safe crowd-pleaser; sometimes called generic

2987
160
•160 positive•0 neg
11
YSL L'Homme

YSL L'Homme

$73.07Amazon
63

TL;DR: Classic, versatile & classy ginger scent; huge compliment getter; performance issues with newer batches

11591
130
•129 positive•1 neg
12
Terre d'Hermès

Terre d'Hermès

$117.04Amazon
60

TL;DR: Classy, mature & versatile; woody, citrusy & earthy notes; considered a masterpiece; Eau Givree is a fresher flanker

2078
177
•177 positive•0 neg
13
Montblanc Explorer

Montblanc Explorer

$136.00Amazon
56

TL;DR: Popular Aventus clone; affordable & versatile; gets compliments; performance issues for some

1375
139
•139 positive•0 neg
14
Viktor & Rolf Spicebomb

Viktor & Rolf Spicebomb

$155.00Amazon
55

TL;DR: Warm, spicy & masculine scent; Extreme version is very popular & gets tons of compliments; great for cold weather

1383
153
•153 positive•0 neg
15
Prada L'Homme

Prada L'Homme

$79.89Amazon
52

TL;DR: Clean, soapy, professional scent; perfect for the office; inoffensive & classy; L'Eau is a fresher alternative

1278
131
•131 positive•0 neg